Referencing Part 4 for a moment, I’d like to take another look at the Raines-Logan meeting for a moment. It consists, as I said, entirely of Raines needling Logan, actively trying to provoke the man trying to return order to the country. Because he’s a liberal. And banned guns. Both of which have him roasting in the pits of Hell in Johnstone’s way of thinking.
When I write these, I tend to listen to the soundtrack to Les Miserables, and wouldn't you know that I was listening to "The Confrontation" while I was writing that section.
For those of you unfamiliar with the musical, "The Confrontation" is, of course, the first real confrontation between Jean Valjean (the protagonist) and Javert (the semi-antagonist) of the show following the musical's prologue. Valjean once stole a loaf of bread to save his sister's starving child. Javert, an ardent devotee of the law, believes that this makes him an evil criminal for life, and through a combination of Javert's persistence and Valjean's bad luck, the two meet up several times in the story. "The Confrontation" is definitely my favorite of these meetings, because it examines both characters in surprising detail, provides more backstory for Javert, and is actually a very good number, especially the 10th Anniversary version
You can listen to it here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2WdoAnlQ30U
This is, in my mind, the most perfect confrontation scene ever written. Both the protagonist and the antagonist are clearly defined, both set out their motivations and, best of all, you can see both sides of the argument. Valjean is a good man trying to do good deeds...as well as a wanted criminal who is often quite willing to break the law to do above-mentioned deeds. In addition, if you watch the entire play, you find that Valjean jumped his parole, and tried several times to escape from his jail sentence. Javert, by contrast, is sentencing a young girl to suffer. But, at the same time, he's doing his duty, following his personal convictions, and honestly believes he's making the world a better place. Maybe it's just my rather unique vantage point, but I actually have a liking and respect for both characters.
Needless to say, Johnstone’s meeting isn’t handled half as well. Raines comes off as some kind of arrogant sociopath, while Logan comes off as an overworked man in a bad position who’s being insulted because of something he did before civilization essentially collapsed. Since then, he has been gradually using his influence and the manpower under him to reclaim part of the country, and restore peace and order. Despite this, it’s clear that we’re supposed to cheer for Raines when he finally forces Logan to break. There is no ambiguity as to who is right or wrong; Raines is always right, in everything he does. In addition, there’s no drama to the piece, and it only serves to introduce Logan; compared to the song, where you can almost feel the buildup to the (admittedly brief) fight about 2/3 of the way in, it’s almost pathetic.
Yes, I know I'm comparing one of the best musicals ever written with a piece of trashy pulp, but I think it's obvious that this is supposed to be Johnstone's magnum opus, so I hold it to very high standards. When and if I ever review Stephen King's Dark Tower series, I plan on comparing them to the creme de la creme as well.
But let's get back to the plot. It's been three days since I actually posted one of these things, and I want to get this done sooner rather than later.
When we last left Ben Raines, he’d abandoned a pocket of humanity (after an apocalypse, mind) because they had the GALL to have a former Democrat as their leader, and found out that he’s been appointed the leader of the Rebels. So, given that we’ve spent the better part of a week following his character, what do we expect him to do? I’ll even give you a few choices.
A) Realize he’s a moron, go back to Logan’s stronghold, and help him rebuild the US, hoping to curb his evl librul tendencies?
B) Take control of the Rebels, form his own country, and offer an alternative to Logan’s evl librul nation?
C) Ignore both factions, return to his home (which is probably a doom fortress), and wait to see what happens?
D) Continue his rather stupid idea that he’s the only writer left in America and travel through the increasingly dangerous territory to write down survivor stories. Which, if the country survives, will probably come out anyway.
If you chose anything but option D, you clearly haven’t been reading these reviews at all. Go back and read them, you lazy fellow. Or, better yet, stop reading them and go find something decent.
Anyway, let’s get back to our increasingly villainous protagonist, ja? So, after murdering two men and abandoning a group of men trying to reform the country to their fate, where’s Raines headed next? Well, he heads north, towards Cairo. He spends a little time in some little no-name town and encounters a couple of zombies (see previous posts for my ranting on said zombies) shuffling around. So how does Raines react to these poor people? He says “to Hell with it” and leaves them to starve. He continues north, finally reaching Cairo, where he’s attacked by bandits. After establishing that there’re no women with him, they decide to capture him anyway, assuming he’s “a kid and pretty enough.”
…
This is something of a central theme with Ashes villains. Aside from the ones who later join the forces of light (with one notable exception), almost every Ashes villain is a racist, bisexual child rapist, at best. And gleeful about it, may I add. Although, a problem presents itself in this particular case; why do they not notice that the guy behind the wheel of this large truck in his mid-40’s? I mean, they’re obviously watching him; is the glass tinted or something? Off course, at the end of this little section, Raines kills them. It’s about now that you start having to root for Raines. Why? Because, as I said above, almost every single Ashes villain is far worse than he is.
So, Raines travels the nation and witness how mostly the only ones who aren’t zombies are “scum and slime”. Finally, he heads to Chicago, where he comes across an honest-to-God race war. I recently read a Conservative Republican manifesto; apparently, one of their “chief beliefs” is that racism is dead. And that women are all most happy in the home, but that’s a whole ‘nother can of worms. Point being, despite Johnstone defining himself and his heroes Conservative Republicans more often than anything else, Raines himself barely fits the modern definition. Which I find positively hilarious for some reason.
Okay, so apparently a race war is building in Chicago between the blacks and the whites, and there’s 15-20k people left alive in the city…huh? You mean to tell me that Chicago wasn’t considered important enough to warrant a nuke, or a germ warhead at least? And why, for the love of all things good and well-written, does nearly the entire remaining population of Chicago suddenly want to kill each other? In a situation like this, why oh why does Chicago become the racism capital of the US? Apparently, it’s every man, woman, and child in the city, divided along race lines, ready to kill each other immediately. No one even trying to sue for peace.
For once, Ben does the rational thing and leaves the city be. He stops at a motel just before dark to bed down for the night, and there meets a black party. It turns out, though, that these are good black people. How can we tell? Because their leader, Cecil Jeffries, actually speaks proper English! Yep; nearly every non-Rebel African American in the series speaks Ebonics, and only Ebonics, and THAT is usually how you can tell the good guys from the bad guys. It gets irritating, trust me.
So, despite knowing each other for all of a minute, Jeffries offers Raines some supper, which Raines accepts. It’s also here that Raines and Jeffries come together to reminisce about Vietnam. Raines reveals that he’s a Hellhound, who as we may recall are supposed to be so secret that only about five percent of the US government are even vaguely aware of its existence. Despite this, Jeffries seems to know all about it, and the two men hit it off famously.
When we finally get to the dinner scene, we’re introduced to a few minor characters that will appear later in the book. Cecil’s wife, who only exists to give him something to angst about when she dies later, Ben’s Future Wife (a bit part who I’m not even going to name) who he later admits to not really loving, and Kasim. Who is Kasim? Well, he’s a stereotyped radical Black Muslim/Black Nationalist. He played a bit more of an important part in the complete book, but really, he’s just here to fill up space and give Ben someone to beat hate in the absence of anyone else more worthy of it.
So, after some plot exposition about radiation levels in the nuked cities…wait a second here. Weren’t these clean nukes? Didn’t Johnstone himself explain that they gave off such small amount of radiation as to not matter? Was this man so bad at his job that a minor 17-year-old curmudgeon like me with the writing skills of a rabid badger is better able to keep track of his continuity than he was? And this wasn’t even that far back in the story; each section lasts about fifteen minutes, so at maximum, he mentioned this an hour ago. Where was his editor? Did he even have one?
…ah, who am I complaining about? I haven’t got one either; I’m sure I’ve got plenty problems of my own. But my God, man, you could at least TRY.
Anyway, after we get that startling bit of plot discontinuity/exposition, Kasim begins being…well, his stereotype. He asks why Ben didn’t stay in Chicago and help the whites kill the blacks. This results in a rather strained scene where Kasim plays the above-mentioned stereotype to the hilt. He doesn’t trust Ben, which, if Johnstone has decided to explore the young man’s backstory even the tiniest bit, might have made an interesting conflict.
Were I writing it, I would have forced the pair together, shown what happened to bring Kasim to his present state of mind (beyond a pair of explanations about his sister being raped), and shown him gradually working himself past it as he’s forced to work with Ben to survive in this dangerous new world. Sadly, I’m not writing it. Maybe I could create the first ever piece of Ashes fanfiction and rewrite the whole epic to make the most basic amount of sense, but...maybe later.
Back to the story, Kasim calls Future Wife “zebra” (did people still talk like that in ’88?), resulting in Kasim getting slapped by Future Wife, then threatened with a magnum to the face by Cecil. Here, we actually get the barest bit of backstory of Kasim; apparently, his sister was raped by white men, which is what resulted in his hatred of the race. And I’m okay with that; it’s an interesting idea, and if played right, could make for some truly awesome drama. Instead of going down that road, however, Johnstone simply has Kasim scream about how Ben is white, with no attempt to humanize him. Again, we seem him being there just to be there.
Ben offers to leave, and Cecil agrees that it’s probably for the best. Here, we also get a bit of plot exposition; there’s an all-black nation in the former US, named, of course, New Africa. In the course of half a week, this new nation now encompasses the entirety of Mississippi, Alabama, and Louisiana, apparently sticking precisely to the old state boarders. Why? Because.
Here, Raines shows another part of his true nature. He tells Kasim that he’ll leave tomorrow, and that if he ever sees Kasim again, he’ll kill the young man. Why? Because, despite not being an evl librul, he represents racism. While I agree that racism is an evil that could stand to be purged from the Earth, isn’t that taking it a bit too far? Half a week ago, you were apparently a mostly lawful citizen. Now, you’re randomly threatening to kill people for expressing their beliefs in a mostly non-physical manner.
I wonder, what’s it like in the Raines household when he finishes the orange juice?
Raines: I tell you, I did not finish the orange juice!
Stereotype Family Member: Yes you did, dear/dad/uncle/whatever! I just saw you swigging the last of it!
*Raines blows family member away*
Raines: So, who really finished the orange juice?
After this, we get a meeting (again rather strained, though I think it's supposed to sound natural) between Ben and Future Wife, where they discuss the differences between the races. It really serves no purpose, so I’ll leave it alone. Here, we reiterate Ben’s plan to travel and write a book about WW3. They kiss. Which I suppose is plausible. I mean, they DID only meet hours ago, but they’re at what could well be the end of the world as they know it forever. People are trying to rebuild the country, but hey, they’re just stupid liberals, what can they honestly do?
The next day, Ben departs. As is usual for Ashes villains, Kasim rants at him for their entire meeting. Ben handles it coolly and drives away. Thankfully, we will never see Kasim again.
We get some more scenes of Ben interacting with the zombies. Here’s one of their responses to Raines pointing out that there’s probably not a stable government anywhere in the world: “You’re wrong, mister. If the government wasn’t going to help us, they wouldn’t have made everybody so dependent on them. You’re wrong!” Stupid lines aside, is this how much respect this man has for the average American? I thought we Americans were supposed to be the greatest thing since sliced bread! According to my own Conservative Republican family member, it’s another core belief of the entire freakin’ ideology!
Maybe I should just ignore the "good Republican" line of reasoning and just assume Johnstone's creating his own ideology.
Ah, why do I bother? As we approach the end of this section, we watch as Ben discovers a freaking billboard from the Rebels to him, asking him to call them and publicly telling him which radio frequency to use. Isn’t that just mildly stupid? Not only could such things be easily vandalized or torn down or painted over or what have you, but it also gives whoever feels the need to fight you a way to pinpoint your location. I don’t know if the technology to do that actually exists, but Johnstone makes mention of it in later books, so let’s assume it does.
As the section ends, Ben refuses the call to lead the Rebels and moves on. Why? In the very first section, he said the only reason he wouldn’t join up with the Rebels in the first place is because he’d become content with his way of life. His way of life is now shattered, and he’s got the military power, apparently, to recreate the US in his image, as he no doubt wishes to do. So why doesn’t he do it?
He must have a really good book in the works.
